Initiative180

Initiative#26: Bus conversations and question marks

I perceive buses as solitary places, not places for conversation or making friends.

I’m also rather terrified of the oddities that board on; I’ve seen some nasty, nasty characters who scream at other passengers, leer and make sexually inappropriate comments, or attempt to pick a fight.

Clearly I’ve taken too many buses.

But when I saw a fairly nice looking chap carrying this book

I was so excited to see someone reading Indonesian, a language very close to home for me that I actually blurted out ” Can I have that book please?” Smooth Steph..smooth. Haltingly, he looked at me and I made a split second decision to say..hi. (Smile and repeat, that’s the trick)

We ended up having a wonderful conversation about Bahasa Indonesia and he spoke so fluently! He’s just learning it for fun but somehow, his hunger for the language and culture far surpassed my native advantage. I stuttered and stumbled clumsily around the language of my youth so badly that I just stopped trying at one point and moved the conversation to Indonesian pop music instead.

He also plays the Gamelan, a traditional Malayan/Javanese musical instrument. Once again, the conversation about the music of my youth made me red faced..because I’ve never actually touched or attempted to learn it before.

Honestly, he put me in deep deep shame. This initiative of mine turned out to be such a humbling and defining moment for me.

This American, so foreign to my culture and language, knew more about the going-ons in my neighbouring country than I did. He was far more enthusiatic about the local Malaysian/Indonesian music scene and could easily rattle off her and their latest songs, albums, band drama, etc. He read Indonesian literature for fun and taught himself how to pronounce and sing in Indonesian too.

He knew more about my culture (and my people) indirectly than I did.

WOW. Let me just repeat that…WOW.

I felt like such an Anglophile that I retreated to my Iphone and started hunting for Malaysian music on Youtube. To be honest, I got rather nostalgic at one point. Anything remotely Malaysian/Indonesian turns me inward and forces me to grasp for air.

This incident also reminded me of a train commute conversation I had back home ( my first actually!)

I remember sitting down with a book, trying to internalize the idiosyncrasies of American life – song, dance, culture and all and struggling so hard when an American lady (presumely) sat down next to me and proceeded to ignite a conversation. I remember shooting bullet like questions at her about the American lifestyle, noting her accent, and deep down, craving to BE her.

I have felt it many, many times before; this impulsive longing to learn about another culture, to be part of it, to breathe, eat, and live with it.

To me, culture is this ever-changing entity that is entirely man made. It is inherited, adopted, adapted, and in some cases, replaced.

My question is : Where do the boundaries lie between adapting a culture into one’s own inherited culture and totally replacing it?  How do we protect our cultural identity when we start practicing the lifestyle of a different culture…if you think it should be protected at all?

Maybe bus conversations aren’t that bad after all.

Comments

The title grabbed me because I’m going on my first bus ride (Chinatown Boston to Koreatown NYC) in a few weeks and am almost as excited about that then I am for the destination.

I love learning about cultures, maybe it is because I’ve lived in many different places but there is always a slew of others to learn about.

To your question: Having this man remind you of where you came from and you soaking in the American lady’s words is the answer to cultural identity to me. Don’t forget your past, soak in the present and be open to the future.

Sorry so rambling but you’re really making me think and it’s too late for that ;)

posted by CMcKane on 08.13.10 at 12:14 am

Succinct, astoundingly so – “don’t forget your past, soak in the present and be open to the future”.
Wow, I’m going to be thinking about those words for a long long time. Have a great time on that bus ride! I bet you’ll uncover many treasures and express them in equally eloquent words :)

And it’s never too late to think!!! No no no !!!

posted by Steph Lee on 08.13.10 at 3:16 pm

Wow, what an amazing project. I think that culture is what you want to choose. It frustrates me when I see people in America who will not let go of the culture they left behind. I understand, it is their heritage, but I do feel like it causes division within the cohesiveness of our country. I hope you don’t see that as narrow-minded. On the other hand, I do get why a person would want to keep their heritage alive and not allow it to slip away. There must be some gently balance between keeping it alive and yet also embracing the culture in which you presently live. America has some awesome culture of its own!

Just coming by from 31DBBB!

posted by Texan Mama on 08.13.10 at 11:46 pm

[...] Initiative#26: Bus conversations and question marks [...]

Leave a comment

CommentLuv Enabled

Powered by WP Hashcash

blog comments powered by Disqus

Initiative 180 is Digg proof thanks to caching by WP Super Cache